close
close
blog

Trudeau gets an earful on defense spending from nearly one-quarter of the US Senate

Nearly one-quarter of the members of the United States Senate have sent an unusually critical letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau expressing dismay over Canada’s level of defense spending.

They pressed Trudeau to come to this summer’s NATO summit with a plan to fulfill Canada’s commitment to reach the alliance’s longstanding spending target.

The letter from 23 members of the US Senate, from both parties, represents a dramatic and public escalation of pressure from Washington over a longstanding bilateral irritant.

In the note sent Thursday, the senators described this moment as one of the most dangerous in NATO’s history, with tensions on multiple continents. They said allies must keep their commitments.

That written criticism comes just days after Defense Minister Bill Blair completed what he referred to as a productive trip to Washington to promote Canada’s new military strategy.

“We are concerned and profoundly disappointed,” says the letter, referring to the spending levels in the strategy Blair came to promote.

“Canada will fail to meet its obligations to the Alliance, to the detriment of all NATO Allies and the free world, without immediate and meaningful action to increase defense spending.”

The senators noted that Canada’s plan would bring defense spending to just 1.7 per cent of GDP, two decades after NATO allies agreed to a 2 per cent target — which NATO describes as a mininum contribution.

They also suggested that Canada is moving too slowly to modernize the aerospace warning system in the Arctic, saying the North American Aerospace Defense Command desperately needs an upgrade that can’t happen without Canadian cooperation.

G7 leaders, President of the European Council Charles Michel, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskiy pose for a family photo during an event to announce a Joint Declaration of Support to Ukraine, as the NATO summit is held in Vilnius, Lithuania July 12, 2023. REUTERS/Kacper Pempel

World leaders at the last NATO summit in Lithuania last year. US senators are pressing Trudeau and others to have a plan to meet the 2 per cent spending target when they come to the next NATO summit in Washington. (Kacper Pempel/Reuters)

They suggested this issue could come to a head at the upcoming NATO summit in Washington in July. While the letter came from legislators and not the Biden administration, it was signed by a dozen Democrats, some with close connections to the White House.

“Later this year, when the United States hosts the 2024 NATO Summit to lay out priorities for the upcoming year, we will expect your government and every NATO member that has not met the two per cent defense spending threshold to have a plan to achieve this benchmark as soon as possible,” said the letter.

Blair downplayed the senators’ concerns while speaking to reporters in Ottawa on Thursday.

“I’m sure that I’d be able to assure those concerned senators that Canada will be a ready and capable ally to NATO,” he said.

A number of senators who signed the letter — including Democrat Jeanne Shaheen and Republican James Risch — have made appearances at the annual Halifax International Security Forum in the past.

Sen. Jim Risch, the chairman of the US Senate’s foreign relations committee, arrives at a news conference at the Halifax International Security Forum in Halifax on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2019.

Sen. Jim Risch, then chairman of the US Senate’s foreign relations committee, arrives at a news conference at the Halifax International Security Forum in Halifax on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2019. (Andrew Vaughan/The Canadian Press)

The letter stands in contrast to comments the US ambassador to Canada made in April.

Speaking on a panel at the Canadian War Museum marking the 75th anniversary of NATO’s formation, Ambassador David Cohen said the United States takes “a broader view” that goes beyond the alliance’s military spending target for member nations.

“We choose to look at Canada’s overall commitment to defence,” Cohen said.

“We do look at the percentage of GDP that is spent on defense but we look at a wide range of other factors.”

Cohen’s comments came days before Ottawa released a new defense policy that committed billions of dollars in additional defense spending over the next decade.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau stands behind National Defense Minister Bill Blair as they hold a press conference on Canada’s new defense policy at CFB Trenton in Trenton, Ont. on Monday, April 8, 2024.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau stands behind National Defense Minister Bill Blair as they hold a press conference on Canada’s new defense policy at CFB Trenton in Trenton, Ont. on Monday, April 8, 2024. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

But even with those additional commitments, the government estimates that Canada will see military spending hit 1.76 per cent of GDP by 2029-30 — still short of the NATO benchmark.

Blair pointed to the new policy as a sign Canada is working on increasing spending.

“Canada is on a very strong upward trajectory in defense spending. We know we’ve got work to do, we’ve acknowledged that since day one,” he said.

“We’ve clearly indicated in our budget the path to getting that done.”

In the NATO alliance, Canada spends less on defense almost than any other country as a percentage of its economy. But because it is wealthier than most NATO members, Canada spends more in current dollars than all but a handful of NATO members.

The US has for years pleaded with allies to spend more on defense. That pressure only escalated under the last president, Donald Trump, who has suggested allies that don’t spend enough on their own defense don’t deserve US protection against invasion.

The pressure for allies to do more is growing, as the US faces unprecedented challenges. The US is now spending more to pay off the interest on its national debt than it does on defence, and its weapons manufacturing industry is plagued by notoriously long delays, as several rivals, including Russia and China, built up their own militaries.

Related Articles

Back to top button